Eternal Blue by Spiritbox album cover

Album review · 2021

Spiritbox - Eternal Blue

Spiritbox

Released
2021
Genre
Metalcore
Label
Rise Records
Styles
djentnu metalpost-metalcorealternative metal
Producers
Daniel Braunstein, Mike Stringer
Features
Sam Carter
Read time
13 min
Published
7.7

The scorecard

7.7/10 · Great

How we score →
Songwriting25%
7.5

Songs like Circle With Me and Secret Garden prove Spiritbox can write actual hooks instead of cycling riffs, though filler such as We Live in a Strange World shows they have not learned to edit yet.

Sound25%
8.5

Daniel Braunstein's mix gives the synths room to breathe without softening the guitars, and the tone shifts from Holy Roller's scrape to Constance's shimmer without the record sounding pasted together.

Performance15%
8.0

Courtney LaPlante moves from the speech-rhythm screams on Yellowjacket to the breathy melodies on Circle With Me without either mode sounding like a costume, and Mike Stringer plays riffs that stick instead of showing off.

Cohesion15%
7.0

The sequencing earns the leap from Holy Roller to Eternal Blue, but twelve tracks is two or three too many when Halcyon and We Live in a Strange World add little the earlier songs did not already say.

Originality10%
6.5

Blending nu metal heaviness with synth-pop structure was not invented here, but Spiritbox makes it sound like their own idea instead of citing Deftones as an excuse, and the drop-tuned djent never devolves into Periphery worship.

Replay value10%
7.5

Holy Roller, Circle With Me and Constance hold up after dozens of plays, though the atmospheric interludes lose their impact once the mood is established and the weaker tracks become skips.

Spiritbox Eternal Blue — The Debut That Rebuilt Metalcore With Synths and Restraint

The argument for Eternal Blue is simple: Spiritbox wrote a metalcore record that trusts melody and space as much as breakdowns, and it works because Courtney LaPlante and Mike Stringer committed to both extremes instead of hedging. The songs that land—Holy Roller, Circle With Me, Constance—prove you can drop-tune to F# and still write hooks a pop songwriter would recognize, and the production gives the synths enough weight that the clean sections feel like part of the album instead of breathers between the heavy parts. The stakes matter because metalcore in 2021 was stuck: the Architects school had run the emotional-breakdown formula into the ground, the proggy bands were writing for other musicians, and the old guard was either broken up or playing the same album on tour for the fifteenth year. Eternal Blue arrived with a different answer, one that borrowed from nu metal's directness and 80s dark pop's structure without sounding like either, and the fact that it came from a band with one EP and a pile of singles made the execution more surprising.

Spiritbox formed in 2017 after LaPlante and Stringer left Iwrestledabearonce, and they spent the next three years releasing singles instead of committing to a full-length. The delay paid off: by the time they finished Eternal Blue in early 2021, they had tested the formula in front of an audience and knew which ideas worked. The record was produced by Stringer and Daniel Braunstein and recorded over three weeks in February 2021 in Joshua Tree, isolated enough that the band could finish the writing in the studio. The isolation shows in the focus—twelve tracks, none longer than four and a half minutes, with the stylistic range mapped out in the first half so the second half can develop it. What keeps the album from greatness is the same thing that makes it impressive: Spiritbox tried to fit every idea they had into one debut, and the back half sags under the weight of songs that restate the thesis without adding to it.

Drop Tunings, Synth Pads, and the Riffs That Connect Them

The sound Spiritbox built on Eternal Blue works because the guitars and the electronics occupy different registers instead of fighting for the same space. Stringer plays in drop F# and occasionally lower, tuned down enough that the riffs hit like Meshuggah without the rhythmic complexity, and Braunstein's production keeps the tone tight and defined instead of letting it turn to sludge. The synths run from atmospheric pads on Secret Garden to industrial stabs on Yellowjacket, and the mix places them high enough in the frequency range that they add texture without covering the guitars. The contrast between the two elements gives the record its dynamic range: when Holy Roller shifts from the verse's synth pulse to the breakdown's pick-scrape riff, the impact comes from the tonal gap as much as the tempo change. Stringer's playing matured from his Iwrestledabearonce work—he stopped cramming notes into every measure and started writing riffs that develop across a section instead of resetting every two bars. The result is songs that feel composed rather than assembled, even when the structures follow metalcore's verse-chorus-breakdown template.

LaPlante's vocal performance carries the record because she makes the clean and harsh sections sound like two parts of the same instrument instead of two singers trading off. Her screams on Yellowjacket use a speech rhythm that comes from 90s alt-rock, barking phrases instead of sustaining growls, and the approach gives the harsh vocals a percussive clarity that cuts through the mix without needing to be louder than the music. The clean singing on Circle With Me and The Summit takes influence from Charli XCX and the Weeknd—breathy, rhythmically precise, melody-forward—and the style works because LaPlante commits to it instead of hedging toward rock phrasing. The flexibility lets Spiritbox move between moods without the shifts feeling arbitrary: the leap from Holy Roller's demonic snarl to Eternal Blue's new-wave melancholy scans as intentional sequencing rather than whiplash. Braunstein's mix balances the vocals against the wall of guitars and synths without burying either, a harder trick than it sounds when the arrangement includes that much low-end information and that many layered pads.

The weak points come from the writing, not the execution. Halcyon and We Live in a Strange World reuse ideas the earlier tracks already explored—dramatic builds, harsh-clean contrasts, palm-muted chugs under airy vocals—without adding new wrinkles, and both songs feel like they are on the album because Spiritbox had twelve song slots to fill instead of because the tracklist needed them. Silk in the Strings tries for a Wu-Tang Clan-style rhythmic approach in the vocals, but the riff underneath is too busy to let the rhythm breathe, and the track ends up cluttered instead of syncopated. The sequencing hides some of the filler by placing the strongest material in the first seven tracks, but once you know the record the back half starts to drag.

An Album That Peaks Early and Coasts on Sequencing

Eternal Blue front-loads its best songs and trusts the pacing to carry the second half, a strategy that works on first listen and starts to show cracks on repeat. The opening run establishes every tool in the band's kit—atmospheric build, nu metal groove, djent syncopation, pop melody, breakdown—and by the halfway point the thesis is proven. What follows is mostly refinement: the first stretch's formulas return with bigger hooks, earlier approaches get polished with cleaner execution, and ambient counterweights balance out the violence. The sequencing is smart enough to bury the filler in the middle and save the prettiest song for the closer, but the strategy only works if you play the album straight through. Once you start skipping tracks the architecture falls apart, and you realize the record would have been stronger at nine or ten songs.

The pacing does earn one major transition: the shift from Holy Roller to Eternal Blue, where the album pivots from its heaviest moment to its most restrained. The title track's new-wave synths and sung-spoken verses sound like a different band, and the contrast resets the listener's expectations for the back half. The problem is that the second half does not develop the idea—it just alternates between the heavy and clean modes the first half already mapped. By the time the closer arrives, the ethereal atmosphere feels like a victory lap instead of a revelation, beautiful execution of a concept the album already sold you on thirty minutes earlier.

A Debut That Redefined Metalcore's Ceiling, Even If It Could Not Clear It

Eternal Blue ranks as one of the most important metalcore debuts of the 2020s, not because it invented a sound but because it executed a hybrid approach well enough to make it the new standard. Spiritbox proved you could tune low, scream hard, and still write songs structured like pop instead of like Slipknot deep cuts, and the fact that the album debuted at number 13 on the Billboard 200 showed there was an audience for metalcore that did not sound like Parkway Drive or Wage War. Where the record falls short of classic status is in editing: twelve tracks is too many when three or four of them are restatements, and the back half loses steam because Spiritbox tried to prove too many points on one album instead of saving some ideas for the follow-up. The production and performance are strong enough that the weaker songs do not ruin the experience, but they do keep the album from reaching the level of focus that marks the genre's best work.

This is a record for listeners who want metalcore to evolve past the Architects template but still hit hard, and for fans of Deftones or Tesseract who can tolerate breakdowns. Start with Holy Roller if you want to know whether you can handle the extremes, then move to Circle With Me and Secret Garden to hear the band's melodic ceiling. Skip this if you need riff complexity or if the idea of synth-heavy metalcore sounds like a compromise. For context, play Deftones' White Pony to hear where Spiritbox got the idea that heaviness and atmosphere could coexist, or Architects' Holy Hell to hear the metalcore formula this album was reacting against. Eternal Blue aged well in the three years since release—the production still sounds current, the songs hold up, and the influence is already audible in younger bands. The album's legacy will likely be as the record that made djent-adjacent metalcore safe for melody, a shift that mattered more than any single song on the tracklist.

Track by track

Track Listing

#Title
1

Sun Killer

Standout

An intro that works because it builds to something instead of wasting time: arpeggiated synths and whispered vocals for ninety seconds, then a drop-tuned chug that sets up the heaviness to come. LaPlante's voice hovers in the mix like a ghost, and the production lets the atmosphere sit long enough to establish mood without dragging. The decision to open with drama instead of a breakdown signals the album's priorities—this is a band that will make you wait for the payoff. Written in January 2020, the track does exactly what the band intended: it works as a live entrance and as an album opener, patient enough to let the tension build. Not filler, but not a song you return to on its own.

2

Hurt You

Standout

The nu metal influence lands hardest here: a downtuned chug riff, a groove that borrows from Slipknot's Iowa, and LaPlante's vocals swinging between sung melancholy and barked aggression. The lyrics trace a toxic relationship, the kind where both people know it is over but neither will leave, and the performance sells the frustration without overselling the angst. The working title was Heavy Clown, a Shawn Crahan reference that makes sense when you hear the groove, and the song earns the nod by playing the formula straight instead of winking at it. Stringer's riff is simple enough to stick, and the breakdown at the two-minute mark hits because the song earned the space for it. A high point in the album's first half, direct and confident.

3

Yellowjacket

Standout

The collaboration with Sam Carter gives the track a guest-spot heaviness, but LaPlante's performance is the reason it works—she alternates between spoken-word verses and full-throated screams, a rhythm borrowed from Butthole Surfers that makes the harsh vocals sound percussive instead of sustained. The speech-scream technique gives the song an inhuman quality, which matches the lyrical ugliness, and Carter's feature adds weight to the breakdown without taking over the track. The only guest appearance on the record, and it justifies itself by making the song heavier than LaPlante could have delivered alone. The riff is a palm-muted chug that builds to a release, and the production keeps the low end tight enough that the syncopation reads clearly. Spiritbox at their most brutal, and proof that they can write a breakdown worth the setup.

4

The Summit

Standout

LaPlante calls this one hard to define, and she is right—it is too melodic to be djent, too heavy to be synth-pop, and too rhythmically precise to be post-metal. The vocal melody borrows from Charli XCX and the Weeknd, breathy and rhythmically locked to the beat, while the riff underneath chugs in a syncopated pattern that never quite resolves. Stringer named this as his favorite track on the album, citing the catchiness, and the hook in the chorus backs him up: it is the kind of melody that sticks after one listen. The blend of pop structure and metal heaviness works because the band committed fully to both instead of splitting the difference, and the production gives the synths and guitars equal weight in the mix. A standout, and proof that metalcore can borrow from pop without sounding soft.

5

Secret Garden

Standout

The most Deftones-influenced track on the album, right down to the working title of Chino, and the romantic sorrow in the melody earns the comparison. LaPlante's vocal floats over a clean-tone guitar riff that builds into a wall of distortion, and the dynamic shift from verse to chorus gives the song its emotional arc. The production lets the synths add shimmer without covering the guitars, and the breakdown two-thirds through lands because the band saved the heaviness for the right moment instead of front-loading it. Written in mid-2019, the song showcases the fluidity LaPlante cited as central to Spiritbox's approach—it moves between clean and heavy without the transitions feeling forced. The hook is strong enough to carry the track, and the sequencing placement after The Summit gives the album a breather before the next assault. One of the best songs on the record.

6

Silk in the Strings

Solid

LaPlante tried to approach this one like a rapper, imagining how Wu-Tang Clan would handle the rhythm, but the riff is too busy to let the vocal syncopation breathe. The track ends up cluttered instead of tight, with the palm-muted guitar and the harsh vocals fighting for the same rhythmic space. The intensity is there—this is one of the heavier songs on the album—but the arrangement needed more air to let the ideas land. The production is clean enough that you can hear every element, which is part of the problem: when this many parts are competing, clarity makes the clutter more obvious. Not a failure, but the weakest of the heavy tracks, and one that could have been cut without hurting the album.

7

Holy Roller

Standout

The heaviest thing Spiritbox has recorded, and the song that broke them into the mainstream. LaPlante takes the role of the Devil, speaking internally to the listener as personified evil, and the vocal performance sells the concept with a snarl that sounds genuinely dangerous. Stringer's pick-scrape technique, borrowed from Gojira, gives the breakdown a visceral edge, and the production keeps the low end brutal without losing definition. The song's structure is pure metalcore—verse, breakdown, verse, bigger breakdown—but the execution is precise enough that the formula does not feel stale. Released as a single in July 2020, it spent seven weeks at number one on SiriusXM Liquid Metal's chart and became the band's calling card. The pitch-shifter tuning changes four times across the track, a technical flourish that serves the song instead of showing off. A landmark track, both for the band and for 2020s metalcore.

8

Eternal Blue

Standout

The title track pivots the album from its heaviest moment to its most restrained, a new-wave song with Depeche Mode and Tears for Fears influences that Braunstein helped the band explore. The synths dominate the mix, arpeggiated and shimmering, while LaPlante's vocal stays breathy and melodic across the entire runtime. The lyrics trace the end of a friendship, the kind of breakup that does not come with closure, and the melancholy in the performance matches the subject. Written early in the album's development, the song works as a palate cleanser after Holy Roller and as a thesis statement for the band's range—this is what Spiritbox sounds like when they strip out the breakdowns and trust the melody. The sequencing makes the contrast intentional, and the song earns its place as the album's centerpiece. One of the strongest tracks, and proof that the band's clean mode is as developed as their heavy one.

9

We Live in a Strange World

Solid

LaPlante wrote this about the anxiety of Spiritbox's growing recognition and the fear of failure, but the song does not add much to the album that the earlier tracks did not already say. The riff is a palm-muted chug, the vocal alternates between clean melody and harsh barks, and the structure follows the verse-chorus-breakdown template without variation. The production is solid, but the songwriting is treading water—this is the sound of a band filling a tracklist instead of chasing an idea. At two minutes and forty-eight seconds it does not overstay its welcome, but it does not earn its spot either. Filler.

10

Halcyon

Solid

LaPlante described this as similar to Sun Killer but catchier, and the comparison is accurate: another atmospheric build, another dramatic vocal, another drop into heaviness. The hook in the chorus is stronger than Sun Killer's, and the shift from light to heavy encompasses the dynamic range the album trades on, but the song is restating an idea the record already proved. The production is clean, the performance is committed, and the sequencing places it late enough in the tracklist that the repetition is not obvious on first listen. On repeat plays it becomes skippable, a well-executed song that the album did not need. Solid but redundant.

11

Circle With Me

Standout

The final song written for the album, completed in the studio, and one of the strongest. LaPlante traces her emotional arc from anxiety to empowerment, and the lyric's journey matches the music's build from breathy verses to a full-throated breakdown. The Evanescence and Tears for Fears influences show in the chorus melody, which layers guitars and electronics in a way that feels lush instead of overproduced. The contrast between the clean sections and the breakdown works because the band earned both extremes—this is not a pop song with a breakdown tacked on, it is a metalcore song that trusts melody as much as heaviness. Released as a single in April 2021, it topped the Hard Rock Digital Song Sales chart and reached number five on the Hot Hard Rock Songs chart, and the commercial success makes sense: this is the most accessible song on the album without being a compromise. A career-defining track.

12

Constance

Standout

An ambient closer dedicated to LaPlante's grandmother Phyllis, who died during the pandemic before LaPlante could say goodbye. The song strips out the heaviness entirely—no breakdowns, no harsh vocals, just clean guitar arpeggios, synth pads, and LaPlante's voice floating over the arrangement. The production gives the track space to breathe, and the restraint makes the emotion land harder than a big finale would have. The ethereal approach is the polar opposite of Holy Roller, and the sequencing contrast is intentional: this is the album proving it can do both extremes and everything in between. The song works as a closer because it offers resolution instead of just fading out, and the dedication to Phyllis and the video director's grandmother Constance gives the track a weight that transcends the music. Beautiful, and the right way to end the record.

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes Spiritbox Eternal Blue different from other metalcore albums?
Eternal Blue blends djent heaviness with synth-pop structure and 80s new-wave influences, using drop F# tuning and electronic elements equally instead of treating clean sections as breathers. Courtney LaPlante's vocals move seamlessly between breathy pop melodies and harsh screams, while Mike Stringer's riffs prioritize hooks over technical showboating. The approach borrows from nu metal's directness and Deftones' atmosphere without sounding derivative.
Is Spiritbox Eternal Blue good for metalcore fans who don't like clean vocals?
Only partially. Tracks like Holy Roller, Yellowjacket, and Silk in the Strings deliver brutal breakdowns and harsh vocals, but half the album relies on clean singing and synth-driven atmosphere. If you need constant heaviness, the back half will test your patience. The production keeps the heavy tracks genuinely heavy—this is not metalcore watered down for radio—but the record's thesis is that both extremes belong on the same album.
Which Spiritbox songs should I listen to first from Eternal Blue?
Start with Holy Roller to hear the band at their heaviest, then Circle With Me for their melodic peak, and Constance for their ambient extreme. Those three tracks show Spiritbox's full range and prove whether the hybrid approach works for you. Secret Garden and The Summit fill in the middle ground between clean and heavy, while tracks like We Live in a Strange World are skippable filler.
How does Eternal Blue compare to Deftones and Architects?
Eternal Blue takes Deftones' heavy-atmospheric balance and applies it to modern djent tuning and metalcore structure, with more rhythmic precision and electronic elements than Chino Moreno ever used. Compared to Architects' emotional breakdowns and anthemic choruses, Spiritbox leans harder into pop songcraft and restraint, trusting melody and space where Architects would add another gang vocal. The result splits the difference: heavier than late Deftones, more melodic than Holy Hell-era Architects.

Genres

Styles

djentnu metalpost-metalcorealternative metal